Everyone loves a good panini, especially if you can make it right in the comfort of your own home. Let’s take a look at some of the absolute best options from 2018 for your own panini press.
The market for these machines is pretty enormous, and there are so many brands, designs, and prices to choose from. Since it can be a difficult process to sift through the market of panini presses, we wanted to help you out and do it for you.
We are going to be rating these products on a 1 to 5-star scale, and we do this by measuring a few different aspects and qualities of each product. Let’s discuss those first.
How We Choose Our Ratings
It is very important to us that we are ensuring our reviews are honest and accurate. To do this, we take a few additional steps in our research to make sure it is completely thorough and correct.
We make sure to read and research online customer reviews and testimonials. This allows us to get a broader view of what the general public thinks of the product in question. It also gives us insight on any widespread issues or complaints that might not show up anywhere else. We are also able to gather quite a few pros and cons from other customer reviews as well.
We also make sure to thoroughly research the product specifications. By doing this, we are ensuring that if any of our readers buy the product we are reviewing, they know exactly what they are getting. There won’t be any surprises and/or confusion when receiving the item in the mail. This also allows us to identify any potential drawbacks that the product may have as well.
Lastly, we make sure to research the company that makes the items thoroughly. It is important to most customers that they are purchasing products from businesses that they can trust and stand behind. This also gives us insight on a company’s customer service policies, as well as their warranty and return policies.
For this particular list of the best panini presses of the year, there are a few different qualities we will consider. How well it grills/cooks the food, pricing, brand, and aesthetics.
The Best Panini Press Options
Here are our choices for the best panini presses of 2018, counting down to our number one choice. We hope you enjoy making panini’s and many other exciting meals and snacks in your new press!
5. Proctor Silex 25453A Panini Press
- Grills sandwiches of any thickness
- Cafe style floating lid presses down evenly
- 12" x 8.5" nonstick grids
The very first panini press on our list is the wonderful Proctor Silex 25453A Panini Press. This is an incredibly spacious product that can grill sandwiches of any thickness to your liking.
It is an incredibly efficient machine, and can even make several sandwiches at once in its large grilling area. The panini press can be manipulated through several different preheating options that you can choose from, so it is appropriate no matter what type of sandwich you are making.
This press also has both power and preheat lights so that you know when the machine is on and hot, and when it still needs to heat up more. We also really love the cafe style floating lid that evenly presses down on the toasted sandwiches.
The grids for the paninis measures 12 inches by 8.5 inches, making this perfect for two or more people to have in their household. It can also be stored upright when it cools down and you are done using it, so it won’t take up too much space when it is not in use.
You can purchase this panini press on Amazon for $58.67.
The only complaints we saw from customers when it came to the Proctor Silex 25453A Panini Press was that it didn’t have removable plates, which means you cannot remove any parts to wash it. This can be inconvenient and some customers also considered it a hazard since you have to scrub the machine down while it is all still attached.
Our final rating for this panini press is going to be 4 out of 5 stars.
We love the cafe style design, the performance, size, and quality, but we do wish it had removable plates to make it easier to clean afterwards.
4. Lodge LPP3 Cast Iron Square Ribbed Panini Press
- Handle and press are cast as one piece for decades of cooking
- Unparalleled in heat retention and even heating
- Seasoned with oil for a natural, easy-release finish that improves with use
If you are looking for something simpler and definitely a lot less modern, the Lodge LPP3 Cast Iron Square Ribbed Panini Press is the one for you. This is actually a cast iron product that will last you for decades if it is taken care of correctly.
The handle and the press of this product are one, solid piece, which we love. Due to the excellent design and construction, this machine offers unparalleled heat retention and even heating. This means that no matter what you are pressing and/or grilling underneath it, it will all cook evenly.
This is a fairly basic design, so if you are looking for something a little more modern for your kitchen, this is truly not the design for you. However, cast iron is so incredibly easy to take care of, and if you do it properly, it can last you decades filled with high-performance use.
To clean this item, just like with any other cast iron, you simply hand wash, dry and then rub in your favorite cooking oil.
We also love that this product comes pre-seasoned with oil to give you a natural, easy-release finish that will improve with continued use.
If you already have the Lodge 10.5 inch square cast iron skillet, this panini press will fit perfectly. It also works extremely well with skillets that are 12 inches or wider.
The only downsides with this product is that it is pretty large and has to be used on the stove, so if you don’t have skillets big enough it won’t work for you. If you are not a fan of cast iron, this is also not going to be the best choice for you.
You can purchase this awesome panini press online for only $12.89, making it the most affordable choice on our list.
Our final rating for this panini press is going to be a 4 out of 5 stars.
We love how affordable it is and how well it works, but we realize that cast iron is not for everybody.
3. IMUSA USA GAU-80102 Large Electric Panini Press
Next up we have the IMUSA USA GAU-80102 Large Electric Panini Press.
This machine features a wonderful non-stick surface that is both extremely efficient when preparing a ton of food all at once, as well as incredibly easy to clean once you are done using it.
The IMUSA USA GAU-80102 also has an awesome floating hinge, meaning that you can adjust it as you like for your ideal cooking height. No matter what you are cooking and how thick it is, this machine can handle it easily. It also has heat and power indicator lights that give you complete control over its grilling and cooking grilling and cooking capabilities.
The outside is sleek and modern. It is a polished stainless steel and includes cool-touch handles to make sure you don’t burn yourself while cooking or grilling. You can cook sandwiches, vegetables, meat, and pretty much anything else you would like on this panini press.
The only real complaint that we saw from customers was the fact that the panini press does not have an on/off switch. When you need to shut it off you have to just pull the plug out of the wall. While this definitely isn’t a deal breaker for most, it was a slight annoyance that a fair number of customers mentioned.
You can purchase this wonderful panini press online for $61.06.
Our final rating for the IMUSA USA GAU-80102 Large Electric Panini Press is going to be a 4.5 out of a 5-star rating.
We love how big it is, how well it works, the moderate pricing, and the modern aesthetics. The only downside is the fact that it doesn’t have a power button you can press to shut it off.
2. Hamilton Beach 25462Z Panini Press
Another affordable option that we love is the Hamilton Beach 25462Z Panini Press. This product requires little to no preparation, and heats up very quickly for a fast, hot meal.
It has an excellent ingenious, fully-adjustable design that allows you to make a sandwich as thick as you want while still heating it through all the way. It does this with an wonderful cafe style floating lid that presses down heavily and evenly on the entire length of food you stick in it.
The grid is 10 by 8 inches, so it is perfect for an individual or a whole family. It is also completely non -stick, so there are no issues with cleaning it afterwards either.
We also love that it comes in a bright red color to brighten up your kitchen when you are using it.
You can purchase this panini press online for only $20.00, but keep in mind that it is only available to Amazon Prime members.
Our overall rating for the Hamilton Beach 25462Z Panini Press is going to be a 4.5 out of 5 stars.
We love how affordable it is, the colors and design, the size, and how well it works. The only downside is that this item can only be purchased on Amazon Prime, so if you don’t have it you won’t be able to buy it.
George Foreman GRP4842P
Last but not least we have the incredible George Foreman GRP4842P panini press. Just like the brand’s many, many other amazing cooking products, this panini press exceeds all expectations and cooks absolutely delicious food.
We especially like this design because it offers three different machines in one. You get the panini press, a grill, and a waffle maker with this product. This reduces the clutter in your kitchen by giving you all those products in one, and it ensures that you can cook almost anything with the George Foreman GRP4842P.
It also has a high-heat searing burst that raises the temperature of your grill to 500 degrees for 90 seconds, which will give you those restaurant-grade, high quality results for your meat, veggies, and sandwiches.
This machine also has removable plates, so you can safely wash the machine without worrying about it still being attached to everything else.
The only complaint that we really noticed from those who bought this product is that the timer that goes off when your food is ready is extremely loud and cannot be disarmed. While this is great to ensure that nothing gets burned or becomes a safety hazard, it can be slightly annoying.
You can purchase this panini press online for about $85.00.
Our overall rating for the George Foreman GRP4842P is 5 out of 5 stars.
We love how well this performs, how versatile the machine is, the pricing, and how concerned the company is for safety.
Buyer’s Guide for the Best Panini Press
Before buying your panini press, make sure to keep in mind what your budget is and what you will be using the product for. Knowing exactly what you are looking for will ensure that you get the best product and will make it much easier to narrow down your choices.
We hope you have found our list of the best panini presses helpful – which product on the list looks the best to you?